Lateral partner hiring is growing. NALP reports that U.S. law firm lateral hiring rose 16.4% in 2025, the second consecutive annual increase. Among responding firms with 250 or fewer lawyers, lateral partner hiring increased 88.7%. These figures reflect NALP’s survey respondents, not every U.S. law firm. For partners considering a move, an active market creates opportunities, but it does not eliminate the need for careful evaluation.
More options also mean more ways to get it wrong. A lateral move is one of the most consequential decisions a partner will make. Done well, it can accelerate a practice, raise compensation and put clients on a platform that serves them better. Done poorly, it can cost money, strain client relationships and leave you looking for another firm within a few years.
The risks are not theoretical. An American Lawyer analysis of more than 1,100 Big Law lateral partner hires, reported by the ABA Journal, found that nearly half did not remain at their new firms for a full five years. Tenure alone does not establish why a move ended, but it underscores the importance of asking the right questions before making a commitment.
Hazard 1: Moving Before You Understand Your Partnership Agreement
Your current partnership agreement governs much of what happens when you leave, and too many partners read it for the first time after they have already accepted an offer. That is backward.
Before any serious conversation with another firm, understand your notice obligations, how and when your capital account will be returned, how unpaid distributions and deferred compensation are treated, and whether the agreement contains clawback or forfeiture provisions. These terms can determine whether a move costs you nothing or a significant portion of a year’s compensation.
The stakes are real. In June 2026, two former Clifford Chance partners who joined Sidley sued their former firm over an alleged attempt to claw back nearly $5.8 million in compensation under its partnership agreement. The former partners contend that New York law bars the disputed penalties; Clifford Chance has sought dismissal and arbitration under the agreement. The allegations and legal questions remain contested. Whatever the outcome, the dispute shows how significant departure terms can be.
Professional responsibility rules also shape the process. ABA Formal Opinion 489 addresses the ethical duties of departing lawyers and their firms, including timely client communication, protection of client interests, and respect for the client’s choice of counsel. Notice and departure obligations must be evaluated under the applicable agreement and jurisdiction’s rules. Obtain independent legal advice before giving notice, and do not disclose confidential client information improperly during recruiting.
Hazard 2: Overselling or Underselling Your Book of Business
Your book of business is the center of every lateral negotiation, and misjudging it in either direction creates problems.
Underselling leaves money on the table. If you understate what will realistically follow you, your compensation will be built around a smaller number than your practice deserves, and resetting it later is difficult.
Overselling can be even more damaging. Firms may build compensation arrangements, staffing plans and revenue projections around the book you present. If projected business does not materialize, the shortfall can affect your credibility, integration and future compensation. Present assumptions and risks as carefully as you present revenue.
The honest analysis is harder than it sounds. Distinguish between clients who hire you personally and clients who hire your current firm. Consider whether rate differences, conflicts or the loss of colleagues on key matters could change a client’s decision. Present a realistic range rather than a single optimistic figure. Credibility established during the recruiting process carries into your first years at the new firm.
Hazard 3: Choosing a Platform That Doesn’t Support Your Practice
A firm can be prestigious, profitable, and still be the wrong home for your practice.
Ask whether the new platform enhances your credibility with your clients or dilutes it. Does the firm have depth in the practice areas your clients need, creating real cross-selling opportunities? Will its rate structure fit your client base, or will your clients face increases that push them elsewhere? Are there conflicts that could block existing relationships or limit future business? Does the firm have the associate bench and support infrastructure to staff your matters properly?
The right platform should make you more valuable to your clients than you were before the move. If you cannot explain to your top clients exactly why the new firm serves them better, that is a warning sign.
Hazard 4: Underestimating Culture and Compensation Fit
Partners often treat culture as a soft factor. In practice, it is where many lateral moves fail.
Culture at the partner level is concrete. It shows up in how origination credit is shared, how compensation decisions are made and how transparent they are, how much autonomy partners have, how the firm handles disagreement, and whether collaboration is actually rewarded or just talked about. A partner accustomed to an open, formula-based compensation system may struggle in a black-box environment. Someone who thrives on collaboration will feel isolated at a firm built around individual books.
Take the time to meet partners beyond the recruiting committee, including those in adjacent practices you will need to work with. Ask how recent laterals have integrated, and if possible, speak with some of them directly. If the fit is not right, don’t make the move. The cost of a poor cultural match compounds every year you stay.
Hazard 5: Skipping Financial Due Diligence on the New Firm
Firms conduct extensive diligence on lateral candidates. Partners should apply the same rigor in the other direction.
Law firms can and do fail. Stroock & Stroock & Lavan, one of New York’s long-established firms, voted to dissolve in October 2023. That followed a failed merger attempt and the departure of more than half its partnership. The warning signs at struggling firms often surface well before a collapse: sustained partner departures, leadership turnover, merger talks that go nowhere, rising debt and capital calls.
Before joining, understand the firm’s financial position, its capital structure and debt, its partner retention trends, its leadership succession plan, and its strategic direction. Ask how the firm performed in difficult years and how it treated partners during them. A firm that is a likely acquisition target or under financial strain may still be the right choice, but you should make that decision with full information.
Independent market intelligence can help partners ask better questions about a firm’s growth plans, potential combinations, leadership stability and market reputation. On Balance Search Consultants helps attorneys evaluate those considerations alongside the financial and operational information they obtain directly from a prospective firm.
Know Why You Are Leaving Before You Go
Every lateral move should start with an honest answer to one question: why are you leaving?
If the answer is a specific, fixable problem, explore whether it can be resolved at your current firm first. A direct conversation about compensation, resources or your role may produce a better outcome than a move, and it preserves relationships either way. Burning bridges carries a long-term cost in a profession where reputations travel, and former colleagues become opposing counsel, referral sources, and clients.
Consider how a move affects your long-term plans as well. If you are a senior partner, think about how changing firms affects your succession plan and the transition of your client relationships. Calculate what you may be leaving behind, including unpaid distributions, deferred compensation, and capital, and weigh it against the realistic upside of the new opportunity.
“I’ve seen attorneys accept lateral offers because the money was attractive, only to discover that the firm wasn’t the right fit. Before long, they were looking to make another move. Compensation matters, but so do the culture, the people, and whether the platform supports your practice and your clients. A bigger paycheck doesn’t always mean a better opportunity.”
– Shari Davidson, President, On Balance Search Consultants
Build an Integration Plan Before Your First Day
Many lateral moves that fail do so after the offer is accepted. A partner who arrives without a plan for introducing clients to new colleagues, building internal relationships and generating cross-selling opportunities can find the first year far harder than expected.
Before you start, work out a lateral integration plan with your new firm. It should cover client introductions, subject to client consent and professional obligations; relationships with other practice groups; marketing and business development support; and realistic goals at 6, 12 and 24 months. An integration plan does not guarantee success, but it gives both sides a way to measure progress and address problems early.
Frequently Asked Questions About Lateral Partner Moves
What should a partner review before making a lateral move?
Start with your current partnership agreement, focusing on notice requirements, capital account return, deferred compensation, unpaid distributions, and any clawback or forfeiture provisions. Then evaluate the new firm’s financial stability, compensation system, platform fit for your clients, and culture.
How much notice does a partner have to give before leaving a firm?
It depends on your partnership agreement and the rules in your jurisdiction. ABA Formal Opinion 489 states that firms cannot apply notice requirements in ways that override a client’s right to choose counsel or that punish departing lawyers. Consult experienced counsel before giving notice.
Why do lateral partner moves fail?
Lateral moves can unravel when a book of business proves less portable than expected, the platform does not fit the partner’s clients, compensation or culture disappoints, or integration receives too little attention. An American Lawyer analysis cited by the ABA Journal found that nearly half of the Big Law lateral partner hires studied did not stay five full years; the finding does not by itself establish the causes of their departures.
How can a partner evaluate a law firm’s financial health?
Ask about the firm’s capital structure, debt, partner retention, leadership succession and strategic plan. Look for warning signs such as sustained partner departures, failed merger talks, leadership turnover and capital calls. An advisor with market intelligence can help identify risks that aren’t visible from the outside.
Get a Second Opinion Before You Make the Move
Before major surgery, most people get a second opinion. A lateral move deserves the same discipline. Understand your obligations, present your practice honestly, test the platform and the culture, investigate the firm’s finances, and plan your integration before you arrive. The partners who make successful moves are the ones who treated the decision with the same rigor they bring to their clients’ most important matters.
Considering a lateral move? Before you accept an offer, evaluate the portability of your practice, the firm’s financial position, the partnership terms and the support you will have after arrival.
On Balance Search Consultants helps lateral partners assess platform fit, market opportunities and long-term career strategy so they can approach a move with clearer expectations and better questions.
For a deeper look at the decisions that shape an attorney’s career, request a complimentary copy of The Arc of an Attorney’s Career. DM CLARITY on LinkedIn or email Shari@OnBalanceSearch.com.
Who’s Driving Your Career?™
Shari@OnBalanceSearch.com | OnBalanceSearch.com | 516-731-3400
All conversations are confidential.
About On Balance Search Consultants
On Balance Search Consultants provides market intelligence and strategic advisory services to law firms and experienced attorneys. Shari Davidson, President, advises on lateral partner transitions, law firm growth, leadership succession, and attorney career strategy. Working with both firms and attorneys, On Balance helps align long-term objectives with the right platform, leadership structure, and growth strategy.
Contact: OnBalanceSearch.com | 516-731-3400
Disclaimer: This content is provided for informational and educational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should consult qualified legal counsel regarding their specific circumstances and applicable legal requirements.
Sources
NALP, “U.S. Law Firm Lateral Hiring Shows Broad Growth in 2025.” https://www.nalp.org/0526research
ABA Journal, “Where are they now? Nearly half of lateral partner hires don’t stay full five years.” https://www.abajournal.com/news/article/where_are_they_now_nearly_half_of_lateral_partner_hires_dont_stay_full_five
Bloomberg Law, “Ex-Clifford Chance Lawyers Fight Firm Over $5.8 Million in Pay.” https://news.bloomberglaw.com/litigation-finance/ex-clifford-chance-lawyers-fight-firm-over-5-8-million-in-payhttps://news.bloomberglaw.com/esg/ex-clifford-chance-lawyers-fight-firm-over-5-8-million-in-pay
Bloomberg Law, “Clifford Chance Fires Back at Ex-Partners in $5.8 Million Suit.” https://news.bloomberglaw.com/business-and-practice/clifford-chance-fires-back-at-ex-partners-in-5-8-million-suithttps://news.bgov.com/business-and-practice/clifford-chance-fires-back-at-ex-partners-in-5-8-million-suit
ABA Journal, “ABA ethics opinion emphasizes ethical responsibilities of departing lawyers and law firms.” https://www.abajournal.com/web/article/aba-ethics-opinion-emphasizes-ethical-responsibilities-of-departing-lawyers-and-law-firms
ABA Journal, “After failed merger talks and partner exodus, Stroock plans to dissolve.” https://www.abajournal.com/news/article/after-a-failed-merger-and-partner-exodus-stroock-plans-to-dissolve

